Advanced Network Inference Techniques Based on Network Protocol Stack Information Leaks

Side channels are channels of implicit information flow that can be used to find out information that is not allowed to flow through explicit channels. This thesis focuses on network side channels, where information flow occurs in the TCP/IP network stack implementations of operating systems. I will describe three new types of idle scans: a SYN backlog idle scan, a RST rate-limit idle scan, and a hybrid idle scan. Idle scans are special types of side channels that are designed to help someone performing a network measurement (typically an attacker or a researcher) to infer something about the network that they are not otherwise able to see from their vantage point. The thesis that this dissertation tests is this: because modern network stacks have shared resources, there is a wealth of information that can be inferred off-path by both attackers and Internet measurement researchers. With respect to attackers, no matter how carefully the security model is designed, the non-interference property is unlikely to hold, i.e., an attacker can easily find side channels of information flow to learn about the network from the perspective of the system remotely. One suggestion is that trust relationships for using resources be made explicit all the way down to IP layer with the goal of dividing resources and removing sharendess to prevent advanced network reconnaissance. With respect to Internet measurement researchers, in this dissertation I show that the information flow is rich enough to test connectivity between two arbitrary hosts on the Internet and even infer in which direction any blocking is occurring. To explore this thesis, I present three research efforts: --- First, I modeled a typical TCP/IP network stack. The building process for this modeling effort led to the discovery of two new idles scans: a SYN backlog idle scan and a RST rate-limited idle scan. The SYN backlog scan is particularly interesting because it does not require whoever is performing the measurements (i.e., the attacker or researcher) to send any packets to the victim (or target) at all. --- Second, I developed a hybrid idle scan that combines elements of the SYN backlog idle scan with Antirez\u27s original IPID-based idle scan. This scan enables researchers to test whether two arbitrary machines in the world are able to communicate via TCP/IP, and, if not, in which direction the communication is being prevented. To test the efficacy of the hybrid idle scan, I tested three different kinds of servers (Tor bridges, Tor directory servers, and normal web servers) both inside and outside China. The results were congruent with published understandings of global Internet censorship, demonstrating that the hybrid idle scan is effective. --- Third, I applied the hybrid idle scan to the difficult problem of characterizing inconsistencies in the Great Firewall of China (GFW), which is the largest firewall in the world. This effort resolved many open questions about the GFW. The result of my dissertation work is an effective method for measuring Internet censorship around the world, without requiring any kind of distributed measurement platform or access to any of the machines that connectivity is tested to or from

Off-Path TCP Exploits of the Mixed IPID Assignment

In this paper, we uncover a new off-path TCP hijacking attack that can be used to terminate victim TCP connections or inject forged data into victim TCP connections by manipulating the new mixed IPID assignment method, which is widely used in Linux kernel version 4.18 and beyond to help defend against TCP hijacking attacks. The attack has three steps. First, an off-path attacker can downgrade the IPID assignment for TCP packets from the more secure per-socket-based policy to the less secure hash-based policy, building a shared IPID counter that forms a side channel on the victim. Second, the attacker detects the presence of TCP connections by observing the shared IPID counter on the victim. Third, the attacker infers the sequence number and the acknowledgment number of the detected connection by observing the side channel of the shared IPID counter. Consequently, the attacker can completely hijack the connection, i.e., resetting the connection or poisoning the data stream. We evaluate the impacts of this off-path TCP attack in the real world. Our case studies of SSH DoS, manipulating web traffic, and poisoning BGP routing tables show its threat on a wide range of applications. Our experimental results show that our off-path TCP attack can be constructed within 215 seconds and the success rate is over 88%. Finally, we analyze the root cause of the exploit and develop a new IPID assignment method to defeat this attack. We prototype our defense in Linux 4.18 and confirm its effectiveness through extensive evaluation over real applications on the Internet

Analyzing the Great Firewall of China over space and time

Abstract: A nation-scale firewall, colloquially referred to as the "Great Firewall of China," implements many different types of censorship and content filtering to control China's Internet traffic. Past work has shown that the firewall occasionally fails. In other words, sometimes clients in China are able to reach blacklisted servers outside of China. This phenomenon has not yet been characterized because it is infeasible to find a large and geographically diverse set of clients in China from which to test connectivity. In this paper, we overcome this challenge by using a hybrid idle scan technique that is able to measure connectivity between a remote client and an arbitrary server, neither of which are under the control of the researcher performing measurements. In addition to hybrid idle scans, we present and employ a novel side channel in the Linux kernel's SYN backlog. We show that both techniques are practical by measuring the reachability of the Tor network which is known to be blocked in China. Our measurements reveal that failures in the firewall occur throughout the entire country without any conspicuous geographical patterns. We give some evidence that routing plays a role, but other factors (such as how the GFW maintains its list of IP/port pairs to block) may also be important

Identifying and characterizing Sybils in the Tor network

Being a volunteer-run, distributed anonymity network, Tor is vulnerable to Sybil attacks. Little is known about real-world Sybils in the Tor network, and we lack practical tools and methods to expose Sybil attacks. In this work, we develop sybilhunter, a system for detecting Sybil relays based on their appearance, such as configuration; and behavior, such as uptime sequences. We used sybilhunter’s diverse analysis techniques to analyze nine years of archived Tor network data, providing us with new insights into the operation of real-world attackers. Our findings include diverse Sybils, ranging from botnets, to academic research, and relays that hijacked Bitcoin transactions. Our work shows that existing Sybil defenses do not apply to Tor, it delivers insights into realworld attacks, and provides practical tools to uncover and characterize Sybils, making the network safer for its users

Ethical Concerns for Censorship Measurement

Based on our experiences in measuring censorship in several projects, we frame various ethical questions and challenges that we have encountered. We offer this short document to highlight open questions that we view as important to consider when establishing ethical norms for censorship measurement